Transdermal Delivery Across Intact Skin, Penetrating The Stratum Corneum
Targeted local application, rather than systemic
🧠 Key Rule: "500 Dalton Rule"
- Drugs with molecular weight ≤ 500 Da have a better chance of penetrating the stratum corneum.
- Penetration is still influenced by:
- LogP (lipophilicity) – ideal range: 1–3
- Aqueous solubility
- Charge – neutral molecules penetrate better
e.g: Rapamycin is (~914 Da) while Tadalafil (Cialis) has a molecular weight of approximately 389.4 g/mol. (Dalton (Da) = grams per mole (g/mol))
🥇 1. Ethosomes in Hydrogel/Cream (Best for passive delivery)
- Ethosomes are lipid vesicles with high ethanol content, which fluidizes the stratum corneum and carries the drug deep into the skin.
- 🔬 Ingredients:
- Phospholipid (e.g., soy lecithin)
- Ethanol (20–40%)
- Water
- Drug (the molecule)
- Hydrogel base (e.g., Carbopol or HPMC for gel; cetostearyl alcohol/cream base for cream)
🧪 Process:
- Dissolve lipid in ethanol with stirring (lipid phase).
- Dissolve drug in water (aqueous phase), if water-soluble. If not, add to lipid phase.
- Slowly add aqueous phase to lipid/ethanol phase under stirring → ethosome vesicles form spontaneously.
- Sonicate for 5–10 minutes to reduce vesicle size (optional).
- Mix ethosomes into pre-prepared gel or cream base.
🥈 2. Transfersomes in Hydrogel/Cream
- Transfersomes are deformable liposomes containing edge activators (like Tween 80) that let them squeeze through tight skin pores.
- 🔬 Ingredients:
- Phospholipid
- Edge activator (e.g., sodium cholate, Tween 80)
- Water
- Drug
- Gel/Cream base
🧪 Process:
- Dissolve lipid and edge activator in ethanol or chloroform.
- Evaporate solvent → thin lipid film forms.
- Hydrate with drug-containing water solution → vesicles form.
- Sonicate or extrude to control size.
- Mix with gel/cream base.
🥉 3. Ethanol-Based Gel + Penetration Enhancers
- Ethanol disrupts lipid packing in the stratum corneum. Combined with enhancers (e.g., oleic acid, menthol), it increases permeability.
- 🔬 Ingredients:
- Ethanol (30–70%)
- Penetration enhancer (e.g., oleic acid, DMSO, menthol, limonene)
- Carbopol gel base
- Drug
🧪 Process:
- Dissolve drug in ethanol + penetration enhancer.
- Prepare Carbopol gel in water and neutralize (e.g., with triethanolamine).
- Mix drug solution into gel base under slow stirring.
⚠️ Notes:
- Good for rapid delivery.
- Can irritate skin with prolonged use.
- Less sustained release.
🏅 4. Solid Lipid Nanoparticles (SLNs) – For extended release (lower penetration but better retention)
- SLNs provide a drug reservoir in skin layers but penetrate less deeply.
- 🔬 Ingredients:
- Solid lipid (e.g., stearic acid, glyceryl monostearate)
- Surfactant (e.g., Tween 80, Poloxamer)
- Drug
- Water
🧪 Process:
- Melt solid lipid (~70°C), dissolve drug into it.
- Heat aqueous surfactant solution to same temp.
- Add lipid to aqueous phase under high-speed homogenization.
- Rapidly cool → solid lipid nanoparticles form.
- Add to gel/cream base if desired.
✅ Summary: Best-to-Worst for Skin Penetration
Rank Strategy Penetration Retention Irritation Risk Complexity
🥇 1 Ethosomes in hydrogel/cream ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ Moderate Medium
🥈 2 Transfersomes in hydrogel/cream ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ Low High
🥉 3 Ethanol gel + enhancers ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐ High Low
🏅 4 SLNs ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Low High
See also:
- PLO gel (Pluronic Lecithin Organogel) – popular in compounding pharmacies for transdermal delivery.
- Methyl Salicylate - penetration enhancer - ✅ Very Good - Penetrates skin well; can carry small actives with it. Proven to penetrate deeply and often used to carry NSAIDs through skin.
🔬 Comparison Chart: Topical Vasodilators & Blood Flow Enhancers
Compound Vasodilation Strength Speed Depth Notes
Methyl Nicotinate ✅ Strong Fast (minutes) Shallow–moderate One of the most potent OTC topical vasodilators. Causes visible flushing.
Methyl Salicylate ⚠️ Mild–Moderate Medium Shallow Mostly a counterirritant; blood flow increase is a reflex response.
Capsicum (Capsaicin) ✅ Strong Slow onset, long-lasting Moderate Strong heat and localized vasodilation. May desensitize nerves over time.
Cinnamon Leaf Oil ⚠️ Mild Medium Shallow Mild irritant effect. Less consistent than others.
Menthol (not in your list) ⚠️ Weak–Moderate Fast Shallow Produces a cooling sensation but can enhance penetration and blood flow reflexively.
Niacin (Nicotinic Acid) ✅✅ Very Strong (oral or transdermal) Fast Systemic Taken orally or applied transdermally → intense flushing and systemic vasodilation.
DMSO (Dimethyl Sulfoxide) ❌ Not a vasodilator N/A N/A Not a vasodilator itself, but helps carry other compounds deep into the skin.
Minoxidil (Rogaine) ✅ Strong (medical) Gradual Moderate–deep True vasodilator used for hair regrowth, sometimes compounded for circulation.
Nitroglycerin (Rx only) ✅✅✅ Very Strong Fast Systemic Medical-grade vasodilator for angina; used in patches for transdermal delivery.
PDE-5 inhibitors (e.g., topical sildenafil) ✅✅✅ Very Strong Medium Moderate Experimental use in increasing localized blood flow (e.g., ED or muscle pumps).